Review: Cooler Master Hyper N520 vs. Scythe Mugen 2 vs. Xigmatek Achilles S1284C

by Parm Mann on 15 July 2009, 16:51 3.75

Tags: Mugen 2, Achilles S1284C, Hyper N520, Cooler Master, Scythe, Xigmatek

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qasww

Add to My Vault: x

Scythe Mugen 2 - installation and performance

Installation

Given the Mugen 2's size, installation was always going to be tricky. We found installation to be extremely fiddly, largely due to the small length of Scythe's bundled LGA775 mounting screws - all of which refused to stay in the backplate whilst attempting to install the cooler.

That was only part of our problem, however. Due to the cooler's larger-than-usual dimensions, we encountered clearance issues with our system's EVGA 790i SLI FTW motherboard. If you're using a board with pre-fitted VRM/chipset coolers, be warned that you may struggle to fit the Mugen 2 - and you may experience similar problems with extra-tall memory modules.

In our case, we had to remove EVGA's chipset cooler in order to aid the installation of the Mugen 2, in addition to having to relocate our two memory modules to the slots furthest from the cooler.

Performance

Scythe Mugen 2 - Thermal Performance
System state Idle Load
Ambient temperature 22.3°C 24.4°C
Case temperature 24.6°C 27.2°C
Ambient/Case delta 2.3°C 2.8°C
CPU temperature 36.0°C 54.0°C
CPU/Case delta 11.4°C 26.8°C
CPU/Ambient delta 13.7°C 29.6°C

With the Mugen 2's fan set to run at 100 per cent, we found temperatures to be perfectly adequate - and marginally better than the Cooler Master Hyper N520.

Scythe's large cooling area and well-finished contact patch clearly result in decent thermal performance. Better still, the bundled Scythe Stream 120 Case Fan provides ample airflow whilst remaining relatively quiet.