Review: MSI Wind netbook: is it the Eee-beater we've been waiting for?

by Parm Mann on 7 July 2008, 10:43

Tags: Wind U100, MSI

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qan4u

Add to My Vault: x

Final thoughts

We've been anticipating MSI's Wind for a while, and indeed any other competition to ASUS' Eee, and we're glad to see it finally arrive. If, however, you were expecting a game-changing gust from MSI's direction, you'll be underwhelmed. MSI's Wind is more of a breeze pushing subnotebooks in the right direction.

Wind's keyboard alone is a selling point, and users who've suffered with ASUS' previous attempts will easily be drawn toward it.

In a sense, MSI's subnotebook and similar devices from other manufacturers are a little like Apple's iPhone. They're gorgeous pieces of technology, and you're instantly drawn toward them. They do almost everything, and do it fairly well. However, they're a little too pricey and more of a "want" than a "need".

Despite its potential, the Wind is a next-generation portable device littered with ageing technology. Yes, it features Intel's latest power-conscious Atom processor, but it also has a standard mechanical hard disk drive and a rather basic 1,024 x 600 screen, not to mention Microsoft's on-the-way-out operating system.

Give it say a year, and we wouldn't be surprised to see subnotebooks running dual-core Atoms, 2GiBs of RAM and Windows Vista Basic. We're confident they'll eventually get touch-screens, too. Those additions would make for a truly compelling device.

Right now, at £330, it's a tough choice to make. If portability is essential, the Wind makes for a cracking device. If you're leaning toward performance, £330 will bag you a Core 2-based laptop and you'll probably get some spare change.

Consumers should be aware that the £330 price-tag applies largely to the MSI branding. Head on over to PC World and you'll find an MSI Wind rebranded as an Advent 4211, priced at a much more appealing £279.99.

Irrespective of its faults, the Wind is an impressive competitor to ASUS' Eee and the majority of us here at HEXUS already want one.


HEXUS Where2Buy

The MSI Wind U100 notebook can be pre-ordered from Scan.co.uk for £333.70 and Play.com for £329.99.

HEXUS Right2Reply

HEXUS World Leading HEXUS Right2Reply initiative invites manufacturers, their representatives and vendors which supply HEXUS with products for evaluation, to comment on the articles that we publish. If they choose to respond, we publish their response verbatim.

External Links

Official MSI Wind U100 notebook website



HEXUS Forums :: 18 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
Whilst i largely agree with the review, i don't think the movement of Vista to UMPC's - or sub-notebooks as they're now being called - is a good thing. It is a desktop operating system, and as such is going to suffer if you put it down on a small system with a processor like that. It would be more appropriate to either stick with Linux - perhaps when Ubuntu lends itself more easily to it (as a user friendly package) - or to stick with XP, hardly on it's way out with MS pledging support for a good part of the next decade.

Also, i would personally prefer a small mechanical hard drive - perhaps like the 160GB ipod classic - than an SSD with such a small amount of disk space. Especially since reliable and fast SSD's are prohibitively expensive for a device like this. 4-16GB - even if it's expandable - really isn't enough for today's market. Vista alone will take a large chunk out of it, and if you're running vista then presumably you'll be loading other applications/media on there too. If anything the security that you've got more disk space is a good thing.

Otherwise, it looks like a nice package! Although i would just be tempted to buy a small laptop for that amount of money. Size is of course going to affect cost, but i think it's stupid that smaller, slower units cost more than the larger, faster and cheaper models.

Also, in regard to the battery life, this is going to change from review to review, but a lot of other reviewers have been quoting at least the same as the Eee, if not more - they seem to have got hold of a 6 cell battery, was hexus short changed here?

http://www.laptopmag.com/review/laptops/msi-wind.aspx?page=4
http://www.bit-tech.net/hardware/2008/07/04/msi-wind-u100/1
isnt the PC World one a diff colour (a drab grey) or is the same white and just a crap picture?
From everything I've been reading about the battery situation, the problem arose from a fire in the factory that makes the 6 cell making availability very low. So they've decided to ship it with a 3 cell and you can buy the 6 later on(for which I hope they'll give a discount because of the delay).

I've ordered the advent flavour one from pcworld so should hopefully get it in a few days. Tried in the shop and they thought they may get some this week but not sure.

I did have a play with the one in the shop and compared it to the Eee series. The E series are too small for me(might as well use my htc kaiser) but this screen was useable and it was light as well. Should work perfectly with my web and walk plus plan I have with t-mobile(and I also get to use their hotspots for free).

It all comes down to what you want it for. I already have a 15" laptop which is a few years old(3gb pentium 4 with 1gb and xp) and it works great for me but is too big and heavy for a general walkabout net access pc so this will fit my needs perfectly.

It's not trying to do everything a laptop does and I think this is the problem people will have when looking at umpc's. They are expecting them to be smaller all singing, all dancing laptops, which they're not.
Methanoid
isnt the PC World one a diff colour (a drab grey) or is the same white and just a crap picture?

The one I saw in pc world was a glossy black one and looked really good.
My advent version is currently on the way to me and what won me over compared to the eee 901 is that i cant actually get one and it costs £60 less!!! And the keyboard is by all accounts much better :)