Review: Gainward CoolFX Powerpack! Ultra/2600

by Ryszard Sommefeldt on 16 June 2004, 00:00

Tags: Gainward Coolfx Powerpack! ULTRA/2600, Gainward

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qayt

Add to My Vault: x

Thoughts

I've neglected to touch on cost until the conclusion. It's a giant £600 including VAT at Komplett just now, a good £200 over other retail pricing for 6800 Ultra products. While you get the engineering expertise of a well designed water block for that money, along with everything else needed for a near-silent, closed-loop water-cooling system, there's no doubting that £600 is head and shoulders above any other consumer graphics card on the market.

So the question is simple. Is the extra performance obtained, and the reduction in noise, worth £200 and the integration of a water-cooling setup into your personal computer system? Personally, the answer is no. With other Ultra partner boards hitting roughly the same clocks as an ExperTool driven Ultra/2600 CoolFX out of the box, and their own probable overclocking headroom, I'd suffer the increased noise of an air-cooled board and put the £200 towards a better monitor or something else to enhance your games playing experience.

Gainward will argue that the question of value for money is one that HEXUS shouldn't make on such a premium product, the Ferrari of graphics cards if you will, but to ignore it would be folly.

There's a definite performance increase to be had from the Ultra/2600 CoolFX at 470/1200, but unless the price differential drops to within £100 of the air-cooled board, the Ultra/2600 CoolFX is hard to recommend. Undoubtedly the fastest unmodified consumer graphics card in the world in quite a few scenarios, but not far enough away from boards like the X800 PRO, XT PE and other closely clocked 6800-based cards to be attractive, given the price.

Excellent engineering and large marketing cojones from Gainward, but it remains out of reach for so many gamers.

Score



Pros

Overall, at 470/1200, possibly the fastest graphics card in the world
Excellent water-block
Easy installation
Very quiet

Cons

Poor software bundle, no games
Expensive is not the word
Performance delta to air cooled cards around 450MHz core not big enough to be compelling
No video input

Thanks

Wayne, Andy (enjoy the travels!) and TJ at Gainward


HEXUS Forums :: 16 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
Thanx for the review, but a I have a question.

Driver Optimisations
NVIDIA Trilinear Optimisations - 60.72 - Off
NVIDIA Trilinear Optimisations - 61.34 - Off
NVIDIA Anisotropic Optimisations - 61.34 - Off
ATI Trilinear Optimisations - BETA 4.5 - On

Am I ready this correctly? you benched with nvidias Optimisations off and ATI's on??
If one uses Optimisations on shouldnt the other be benched with Optimisations on also?? or am I not reading this right… Thanx again for the review, been waiting for some retail card reviews…
It's not that simple with regards to their respective filtering options. I've got an article in progress that attempts to address the issue, plus there's millions of threads on a load of forums that explain it too.

ATI's optimisations produce an image that's as close as you'd like to the image that'd be produced with optimisations off. Whereas NVIDIA's optimisations decrease image quality noticably.

That's my basic methodology for the review, but I'll clear it up in a future article.

Rys
I just don't get it. You gave the product a thumbs down in your conclusion and still gave it 8/10?

You suggested everyone stay away from it and spend the money on something else.

So lets just be clear here, what is your review trying to say?
Is it trying to say:
1. We will give you a good final score even if we do not recommend the product in order to keep getting items to review.
2. Your review is purely on how the product performs/works.
3. You do not even know why you are reviewing this product.

This is how I see it - The card is a near-failure. You said it yourself.

Give it the 6/10 it diserves and put a little thing at the bottom that says “if the price was $XXX (or whatever euro money is these days), it would be a 8/10”.

PS. Translate into USD. Save me the trip of trying to figure out your funky money. Everyone knows english and how much the USD is worth.
Deleted
Everyone knows english and how much the USD is worth.

Very little, with the state of the us economy.

HEXUS is a UK-based site, it wouldn't make sense to quote prices in dollars any more than Euros or Malaysian Ringgits.
I take it you were only using retail cards in this review? Hence the X800 XT PE missing from the benchies?