Review: Battle of the Intel Atom netbooks - which one's right for you?

by Parm Mann on 19 September 2008, 17:05

Tags: Eee PC, Wind U100, Aspire One, Dell (NASDAQ:DELL), Acer (TPE:2353), ASUSTeK (TPE:2357), Intel (NASDAQ:INTC), Samsung (005935.KS), Toshiba (TYO:6502), MSI, Kohjinsha

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qapfc

Add to My Vault: x

Final thoughts: which netbook's right for you?

There isn't, for all intents and purposes, a perfect netbook. There's no shortage of manufacturers joining the market, and we've now a large selection of netbooks to choose from - many of them are near identical, and others choose to do things differently.

In terms of aesthetics alone, we'd be tempted by the Toshiba NB100 - it's one of the smartest-looking netbooks to date.

If we really wanted to stand out, have something different, and spend a lot of money, we'd look no further than Kohjinsha's SX3. It's a system that will have all Eee users looking your way with envy.

However, aesthetics and over-the-top features, we feel, aren't the idea behind the netbook. What most users will be looking for is a system that performs well, is easy to use, and costs less than a full-size notebook. With that criteria in mind, the search for the right netbook becomes a whole lot easier.

Despite the number of netbooks now on offer, it's the cheaper options that have the most appeal - namely the Acer Aspire One and Advent-branded MSI Wind.

If cost matters most, there's little faulting the Acer Aspire One. However, the £280 Advent 4211 offers a larger 10.2in screen and its slightly-bigger shell allows for a more roomy keyboard. There's plenty of netbooks to choose from, but these two old timers, we feel, are still the pick of the bunch.



HEXUS Forums :: 13 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
Good review and links. Any Netbook over £300 imho is ott, and pushing into a full spec laptop domain. I am still to be convinced that any netbook is worth over £600.
Very useful read!

I'm currently in a Netbook dilemma. I have a shagged-out old Dell Inspiron 5000 as a spare laptop (which I was given for free) and I like that but I have been considering a Netbook as I do a lot of writing and the battery life in particular on the Dell is very poor. My other laptop is an HP Dragon so with a 20" screen battery life is comparable to the clunking old Dell (not that this is an issue as I didn't buy the HP to be a portable solution.)

If I were to get a Netbook my leaning has been towards the EEE PC 1000H. I would probably up it to 2 GB and maybe try for a 320 GB HD as replacements in there and it's this semi-flexibility in the upgrade path that's made me lean towards it which some of the others don't have. Plus, EEEs seem to have pretty good battery life. However, £350 for something that small is a lot of cash to stump out when - as noted above - you've got full(ish)-spec laptops for not much more. Yet I do like the idea of a dinky netbook… decisions, decisions….:mrgreen:
Problem for me is… I dont want widescreen :( else I would buy one tomorrow

This has been a dilema for me of late trying to choose a laptop replacement for my old 1.2Ghz Centrino

An Atom CPU @ 1.6ghz seems to have the matching performance but I cant live with only 600 lines of screen height :( I dont need it to play dvds or windscreen HD content

My dream machine would be a 12" display 1024 x 768 dual core Atom with a Intel X-25M SSD and window XP.
when are the via nano based netbooks coming out?
Other sites state that the EeePC 904HD tested here is NOT Atom-driven, it uses the underclocked 900MHz Celeron from the 701 & 900. From what I read, that seems to be what the “D” in the model name means.

Ref:-
http://www.amazon.com/904HD-Laptop-Celeron-Processor-Galaxy/dp/B001F0Q9I6
http://www.techarp.com/showarticle.aspx?artno=571&pgno=0
http://eeepc.net/asus-outs-the-eee-pc-1000hd-1000h-904hd-in-taiwan

Unfortunately, I cannot locate confirmation of this on Asus' site, as (at time of posting) it is “undergoing web maintainance”.:rolleyes: