Review: WD My Cloud Home Duo

by Parm Mann on 26 January 2018, 14:00

Tags: WD (NYSE:WDC)

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qadp7a

Add to My Vault: x

Performance and Summary

Performance, at first glance, doesn't appear to be a strong point. We would expect most NAS devices to saturate the Gigabit Ethernet interface, but My Cloud Home Duo managed modest sequential read and write speeds of 98MB/s and 38MB/s, respectively, using our standard CrystalDiskMark test.

We can only imagine the software configuration is hampering synthetic benchmark performance as the drive fared better during real-world use. When writing a 22GB folder comprised of 221 files from an SSD-based PC to the My Cloud Home we managed an average speed of 68MB/s. Copying the same data back resulted in an average read speed of 109MB/s.

Real-world transfer speeds are adequate, but do be aware that My Cloud Home Duo isn't a particularly quiet device. Our PCs are mostly SSD-based, and the mechanical noise of the hard-disk heads can be off-putting when the WD server is located nearby.

Summary

Considering the identified limitations, My Cloud Home Duo ultimately struggles to match established competitors at comparable price points. The concept has potential, and we like the idea of a personal Dropbox for all of your devices with no monthly fees, but WD needs to work fast to add key features such as external backup and shared folders for My Cloud Home Duo to be worthy of consideration.

The Good
 
The Bad
Pretty, for a storage server
Includes WD Red hard disks
Simple setup
 
No external backup options
Doesn't allow for shared folders
Access requires WD app


HEXUS.where2buy*

The WD My Cloud Home Duo is available to purchase from Amazon and Currys PC World.

HEXUS.right2reply

At HEXUS, we invite the companies whose products we test to comment on our articles. If any company representatives for the products reviewed choose to respond, we'll publish their commentary here verbatim.



*UK-based HEXUS community members are eligible for free delivery and priority customer service through the SCAN.care@HEXUS forum.



HEXUS Forums :: 2 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
I own several MyCloud Mirror boxes, and the MyBook Live Duo boxes that came before that. I haven't set up the “cloud” accounts for them; I was content to use the built-in features on my own network. There's a web server built into the box with all the features available even without internet access.

Happily, these features include backup tools to back up directly to USB devices. And shared folders with user authentication with different levels of access, a DLNA server, etc. You can map the drive manually from Windows Explorer or using NET USE commands, and any USB drive plugged into the back shows up as a folder.

It's really strange that these features would be removed on the MyCloud Home boxes.
The earlier MyCloud devices - MyCloud Mirror and MyBook Live Duo boxes - all had the features missing in the MyCloud Home Duo boxes. Backup tools to back up directly to USB devices. Shared folders with user authentication with different levels of access. The ability to manually map drives.

Why remove them?