Review: Company Of Heroes – PC

by Nick Haywood on 9 October 2006, 12:04

Tags: THQ (NASDAQ:THQI), Strategy

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qagzo

Add to My Vault: x

De-briefing and after-action report.



Right then, time to sum up Company Of Heroes.

Firstly, as an RTS, I’m a tad disappointed that Relic haven’t done more with the actual game mechanics. At times Company Of Heroes feels more like a re-skinned Warhammer 40K: Dawn Of War. In fact, if you take a cue from Dawn Of War, defend your base and then rush the map with heavy armour and engineers, you’ll romp through to the end credits in no time. With the high system demands to get Company Of Heroes running with all the eye candy on, many players will have to knock down the quality settings, meaning they’ll get a game that graphically, is on a par with Dawn Of War too…

The pathfinding is a pain the bum too, especially if you try and get any sort of vehicle to form up facing a particular direction. Further, if you call a unit in from the other side of the map, they daft buggers will take the direct route, even if that means walking through enemy territory. When is a developer going to add in a ‘stick to occupied ground’ button for the route finding? At least this means I can call in my troopers without them strolling into a bunch of enemy machines guns or me having to leave the battle to shepherd them along.

Click for larger image


And of course, a major omission is the utter lack of being able to play as the Germans. Sure, I know this game is all about the invasion of Normandy, but how hard would it have been to have had some sort of German campaign? Ok, so we know historically the Germans lost, but even that could be worked into the game… perhaps missions involving holding a bridge for a certain amount of time before blowing it? Or defending an area until reinforcements arrive? Fighting an orderly retreat saving a set number of units? Come on, an RTS with only one campaign is really half a game.

On the upside, the fact I played this all the way through, went back and played it again with different tactics and then went onto play a few skirmishes speaks volumes. There’s something evilly addictive about Company Of Heroes, it’s like a digital version of crack cocaine. I even found myself restarting missions when I was over halfway through as I’d just thought of a better way to do things.

If you’ve got the oomph in your case then Company Of Heroes is going to delight the eye. Debris and dust goes flying from explosions, bullets kick up puffs of dirt, fires crackle through buildings and armour rumbles over the lot. The sounds, be they far off explosions and cries for help or ‘in your face’ machine guns and mortar shells, are brilliant and truly, just from the sound of it, I can now tell you what an MG42 sounds like… even from a couple of hundred yards away.

Click for larger image


The sheer ferocity of the battles on some of the missions lends a desperate feel to the action as you struggle to control the front line, reinforcing where the enemy threatens to break through and at the same time muster enough troops to mount a counter attack. And talk about hard, even on the easy setting, Company Of Heroes offers up a challenge. Try cranking up the difficulty and you’ve got some seriously tough AI to face. But even on the higher difficulty settings, Company Of Heroes still doesn’t overwhelm you with enemies early on… you always have a chance… a slim one, but a chance.

So is Company Of Heroes worth the money? Well, it has to be said that it’s one of the most compelling RTS titles I’ve played of late… there’s just something so rewarding about using some decent tactics and taking a gun emplacement with no losses. That said, this time around Relic have trickled in the units too slowly, so when you really fancy trying out a unit that’s disabled in the production list, you’ll just have to hang on. This does give you a reason to keep playing but it’s also rather annoying.

Even if you take into account all the niggles I’ve just talked about, the fact remains that Company Of Heroes is just too much bloody fun to pass up. Whilst a novice RTS player might find it a bit of a handful on anything other than ‘easy’, anyone who’s played Dawn Of War and has an interest in World War 2 will love it. Put it this way… I’ve seen the wrong side of 4am for the last three nights and my missus isn’t talking to me because of this game, isn’t that recommendation enough?

Pros
Loads of fun that rewards decent tactics
Graphically great if you have a high spec rig
Real weapons and units, all nicely balanced
Historically inspired missions
Brilliantly frantic, desperate gameplay at times
Difficulty balanced just right

Cons
Needs a pretty hefty system to have all the eye candy
AI can be a stupid bugger
No Axis Forces campaign
Ends rather sudde…

It’s TV’s Band Of Brothers but in RTS form

HEXUS Awards

Company Of Heroes – PC

HEXUS Right2Reply

HEXUS World Leading HEXUS Right2Reply initiative invites manufacturers, their representatives and vendors which supply HEXUS with products for technical editorial evaluation, to comment on the articles that we publish. If they choose to respond, we publish their response verbatim.


HEXUS Forums :: 12 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
Nice review. You need a shot of the V2 going off in there somewhere though :P

Thats just an awesome explosion and I think the patch fixed the shield bug(well I haven't seen it since then)
It’s worth noting that all these missions are based on exclusively US Army actions, even though the British, Polish and French were just as heavily involved.

Nono, the USA was the only country to fight the axis powers in the war, anything else is just our attempts to steal some of there glory. :rolleyes:

theres so many examples of this in games and films, sometimes going as far as to change the nationality of people in order to make a good-o'l-fashioned patriotic american story.
You mean like the brave American pilot who single handedly defeated the Luftwaffe in the Battle of Britain, as per Pearl Harbour?

Or, you could take modern history as a cue with Blair famously telling us all how America stood shoulder to shoulder with us in the Blitz…

Ah well.

If I'm honest, Company of Heroes does only focus on the US forces part in the action, which perhaps is a fairer way of arguing it… but even Call of Duty had major British sections… replete with Jason Statham giving us a nice British accent to tell us we're under fire…

Ho hum, I suppose it's waiting in the wings for a Company of Heroes sequel or add-on pack…
Might be trying of a demo in the next couple of days. Though I had the same symptons (gaming till 3am) playing Age of Mythology, I never really liked combat RTS games. But that's maybe because I'm too used to games like Call of Duty, Counterstrike and Unreal.

It has to be said this review at least lets me try the demo version, whilst I didn't bother previous games. ;)
It's well worth it.

Espesh if you can find the Dawn of War bonus pack bundle. You get Warhammer 40K: Dawn OF War AND the Winter Assualt expansion pack for it.. all bundled up with the nice spanky new Company Of Heroes.

Kiss goodbye to going to bed before 4am! :D