Review: LGA1156 cooler shootout: Arctic Cooling, Corsair, Scythe and Zalman go head-to-head

by James Smith on 18 December 2009, 17:11 3.3

Tags: Corsair Hydro H50, ARCTIC COOLING Freezer XTREME Rev. 2, Scythe Kabuto, Zalman CNPS10X Flex, Zalman (090120.KQ), Corsair, Scythe, Arctic

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qaveh

Add to My Vault: x

Final thoughts and rating

So which cooler would we recommend?

Well, as pointed out in our last cooler group-test, which cooler you should go for very much depends on what you hope to achieve.

If for example you're just looking for a replacement cooler for the retail-boxed solution that shipped with your CPU, and you're going to be running at stock speeds, then out of the candidates on test here, the Arctic Cooling Freezer Xtreme Rev. 2 will fit the bill. At just under £30, it's one of the cheapest on test and also one of the quietest.

If however your main priority is to achieve lower temperatures than either the retail-boxed cooler, or indeed a budget cooler,  to allow for some overclocking or near-silent operation at stock speeds, then either the Zalman CNPS10X Flex with one or two quiet fans such as the Noctua NF-P12 or (if your case can accommodate the radiator), the Corsair Hydro Series H50 will meet these requirements rather well. However, if near-silent running is your goal and you choose the Corsair, then you'd either need to swap out the standard fan supplied, or use some form of PWM controller (your motherboard might have the required functionality in the BIOS), to throttle the fan down to around 1,200 rpm or less.

HEXUS Ratings

We consider any product score above '50%' as a safe buy. The higher the score, the higher the recommendation from HEXUS to buy. Simple, straightforward buying advice.

The rating is given in relation to the category the component competes in, therefore the coolers are evaluated with respect to our 'high-end components' criteria.

75%   72%   72%
Arctic Cooling
Freezer Xtreme Rev. 2
Corsair Hydro Series H50
Scythe Kabuto

71%   71%
Zalman CNPS10X Flex (1-Fan)
Zalman CNPS10X Flex (2-Fans)

HEXUS Awards

75%   72%   72%
Arctic Cooling
Freezer Xtreme Rev. 2
Corsair Hydro Series H50
Zalman CNPS10X Flex (2-Fans)

HEXUS Where2Buy

The Arctic Cooling Freezer Xtreme Rev. 2 can be purchased from Quiet PC at a cost of £29.99.
The Corsair Hydro Series H50 can be purchased from SCAN.co.uk* at a cost of £56.89.
The Scythe Kabuto can be purchased from SCAN.co.uk* at a cost of £39.09.
The Zalman CNPS10X Flex can be purchased without fans for £28.62 at SCAN.co.uk or at Quiet PC for £29.99.
The Zalman CNPS10X Flex with 1 x NF-P12 fan can be purchased from Quiet PC at a total cost of £47.98 (Heatsink, Fan(s)).
The Zalman CNPS10X Flex with 2 x NF-P12 fans can be purchased from Quiet PC at a total cost of £65.97 (Heatsink, Fan(s)).

HEXUS Right2Reply

At HEXUS, we invite the companies whose products we test to comment on our articles. If any company representatives for the products reviewed choose to respond, we'll publish their commentary here verbatim.

*As always, UK-based HEXUS.community discussion forum members will benefit from the SCAN2HEXUS Free Shipping initiative, which will save you a further few pounds plus also top-notch, priority customer service and technical support backed up by the SCANcare@HEXUS forum.



HEXUS Forums :: 7 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
Prolimatech Rev. B LGA1156 ready. Blows the others away. End.
ChuvelxD
Prolimatech Rev. B LGA1156 ready. Blows the others away. End.

Have you got a link to the test with the same conditions showing that?
No Titan Fenrir (Christmas edition)?

I thought this was one of the more popular high performance coolers atm, and now comes with 1156 bracket.

Was deciding myself between a Fenrir and an H50 so a shame from my perspective, but interesting findings nonetheless
kalniel
Have you got a link to the test with the same conditions showing that?

I'd also like to know. The Megahalems kicked many of its contemporaries to the curb when it was initially released, hence it's since been cooling my mildly-overclocked Q6600 perfectly well.
Loved this image:




I'd be quite interested in getting the Corsair H50, but am unsure - yet - if it'll fit into a Sugo SG05b case.

Probably not. Shall look into it a bit more (unless someone wants to help :cool:).