Are netbooks the future of the PC?

by Scott Bicheno on 30 January 2009, 07:00

Tags: Intel (NASDAQ:INTC), AMD (NYSE:AMD), NVIDIA (NASDAQ:NVDA)

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qaqur

Add to My Vault: x

What is a netbook?

Another thing to consider is: what is a netbook and what will it be? It seems to be generally accepted that ten inches is the maximum screen size that could still qualify as a netbook and these days they're pretty much defined as having an Intel Atom as their CPU (although Via, with its Nano processor, might have something to say about that).

But screen sizes and resolutions have been growing, features and weight added and prices increased. The line between netbooks and notebooks has been blurring ever more. Surely for us to conclude that netbooks are the future we have to be able to identify what they are first of all.

The debate over the future of the netbook and the PC industry has much in common with the old ‘one converged device versus several specialised devices' debate. You could view the netbook as a convergence of the smartphone and the notebook.

Here's a table summarising some pros and cons of the netbook:

 

Pros

Cons

Portable

Still has to be carried in a bag

Cheap

Not much cheaper than an entry level notebook

Long battery life

Not much longer than full sized notebooks

Cool, trendy

Fads are transient. Apple is better at cool

Low power

Low performance

 

As is the norm with converged devices, every benefit can be offset with a drawback. And this was bound to be the case; you can't just suddenly chop a hundred quid of the price of a notebook and make it more portable without there being some sacrifices. What remains to be seen is whether, in the long term, the mass market will find the pros outweigh the cons.

A look at the recent forum posts on HEXUS stories linked to earlier in this piece shows that there are those who think netbooks are a panacea and those who don't like their compromises. This will always be the case.

Ultimately it oversimplifies the market to say "the future is netbooks", but their popularity certainly puts pressure on the other form factors to justify their existence. To finish we leave you with a vision of what the netbook might evolve into if Huang gets his way. "I want a MacBook Air with battery life that lasts forever for $199," said the NVIDIA boss.

 



HEXUS Forums :: 18 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
IMO manufacturers have forgooten the concept of a netbook and are trying to make them more powerfull like usual, there is absoloutly no point whatsoever t have a dedicated GPU in a netbook the screens are far to small to do anything, surfing the web is annoying at the best of times let alone running photoshop.
Agreed Breezey.

When Asus brought out the EEEpc the whole concept seemed to be very small very cheap computers for web browsing/office stuff. Pricing well under 300 quid and it all looked great.

Now the new sony ones starting at 600 quid and things go bat**** crazy.
Breezey
there is absoloutly no point whatsoever t have a dedicated GPU in a netbook the screens are far to small to do anything
Given that you can easily get a 9 - 10 inch screen with a 1280 x 800 resolution *now* (a couple of the HP netbooks have it already) why not have a GPU that can hardware accelerate 720p content and upscale DVDs (apart form the need for external DVD drive, that is ;) )?

I agree with Pat Moorhead when he said (in a Hexus interview that I'm sure you can find if you want to check) that you can tell there's a gap in the market by the fact that netbook screen sizes increased from 7 -> 9 -> 10 inches fairly rapidly. It suggests people want a small, light but fully functional notebook. What Yukon and Ion should do is bring entry-level laptop performance to a smaller form factor at about the same price. Assuming that happens (i.e. Yukon and Ion based machines cost around £300 - £500) I think netbooks will drop back to sub £250 with max 9" screen, catering for those people who literally just want something to email and surf on while they're out and about.
scaryjim
Given that you can easily get a 9 - 10 inch screen with a 1280 x 800 resolution *now* (a couple of the HP netbooks have it already) why not have a GPU that can hardware accelerate 720p content and upscale DVDs (apart form the need for external DVD drive, that is ;) )?
.

Ok given that the fact a 10“ netbook from HP is around £400 for a decent res , there is no dvd drive so upscaling dvds is out of the question, why not just buy a regular sized notebook or even a 13” with a dvd drive with the intel 4500 onboard gfx as its more than capable of playing 1080p HD so why bother with dedicated when all they really need to do is put a decent chipset in there t start with which will keep costs down rather than adding bits on. Hell my Dell studio runs 1080p wit an x3100 and 8mb of memory.
Net book. It's in the name, and they're not supposed to do much more than browse the web, as Breezy mentioned

Still, if companies can produce a £250 netbook with nvidia 9400 graphics, then why not? As time moves on you're bound to get more features inside the same price bracket.